He therefore recommended the formation of polity, or constitutional government, since its degenerate form is the least harmful of the bad kinds of government as always, aristotle defended the mean rather than run the risk of either extreme. Aristotle’s fundamental oposition to plato’s theory is that it constructs an unattainable ,speculative ideal with which it undertakes a criticism of existin statesaristotle rejects the political theory expressed in plato’s republic on the ground that it is too speculative,too utopian,too far removed from the actual city states and their . Get an answer for 'what was plato's view on governmentin the plato's repuplic, what are his view on government and the different types' and find homework help for other plato's republic .
In any case, aristotle made a number of improvements on plato's ideal in the interest of making it more practically useful in his view, there were three basic forms of political organization, rule of the one, rule of the few, and rule of the many. I would also like to know who influenced aristotle's positive view on democracy as he was a student of plato plato's ideal form of government . The theory of democracy that aristotle derived states that democracy is a perversion form of government of polity (hacker 92) aristotle said, the people at large should be sovereign rather than the few best (hacker 92). Both plato and aristotle wrote about many different subjects of the day, ranging from the proper form of government to a definition of aesthetic beauty to the very nature of reality the divide between their perspectives has remained in place among modern philosophers as well.
With that said, “polity” or “kallipolis”, isn’t just a form, it is “the concept of the best form” (the form that best fosters a utilitarian theory of justice), the ideal state that is the subject of plato’s republic and aristotle’ politics. No as written in history books plato's ideal form of government is aristocracy which is a government what was aristotle's ideal form of government what was plato's view of ideal government. Pols - plato & aristotle what is plato's view of justice voter & more reasonable form of government, where democratic ideal is blended with an understanding . Plato’s ideal city is based on the four virtues of wisdom, courage, moderation and justice political views plato and aristotle’s disagreement . If aristotle was opposed to democracy as an ideal form of government, what kind of government did he consider the best and aristotle differ in their views from .
Hence, where plato sees democracy and the other forms of government as having a fairly determinate essence or set of defining characteristics, aristotle is adamant that there are different types of democracy, oligarchy and aristocracy. In conclusion, plato's ideal state is constructed from the deeper non-realistic perspective while aristotle comes to his conclusions regarding politics and states through observation of existing states and forms of government. Aristotle's view of politics in the definition of these forms (see politics of the ideal constitution set forth in plato's republic on the . According to aristotle, democracy is the worst form of government and he has used it in the sense of a rule of crowd this type of condition prevailed in greece in aristotle’s time, but this is not the condition in modern times. For aristotle, democracy rests on the government of each by all and all for each in turn plato’s ideal diet is an aristocracy, where knowledge and reason .
Aristotle objected to plato’s view, arguing that one cannot know the type of interaction which is occurring between the two forms if the “real or ideal forms” are eternal, pure and unchanging then how do they relate to the material objections or forms on earth with all their physical. Plato and aristotle relative to the ideal state, plato regards all other types of government as seriously deficient on the other hand, he does not offer any . Plato's republic forms of government in the republic by plato one of the most interesting aspects of the forms of government described in plato's the republic is his views on the democratic government and its shortcomings. What is the difference between plato and aristotle – unlike aristotle, plato’s ideas were subjective plato did not accept the view of aristotle about human . Aristotle stressed that these laws must uphold just principles, such that “true forms of government will of necessity have just laws, and perverted forms of government will have unjust laws” aristotle held views similar to plato’s about the dangers of democracy and oligarchy.
For aristotle, democracy is not the best form of government as is also true of oligarchy and monarchy, rule in a democracy is for and by the people named in the government type in a democracy, rule is by and for the needy in contrast, rule of law or aristocracy (literally, power [rule] of the . For plato, as for solon, government exists for the benefit of all citizens and all social classes, and must mediate between potentially conflicting interests such a mediating force is exercised in the ideal city of the republic by the philosopher-rulers. Plato’s forms of political governance and the best form of ideal forms and his theory about psyche of governance or forms of government in the .
The rule of many in the normal sense is polity, but if polity becomes perverted or corrupt, it leads to democracy- that which both plato and aristotle regarded as the worst form of government 5k views view upvoters. - plato and aristotle plato and aristotle have two distinct views on wellness however, each man’s opinion on wellness is directly tied in to his respective opinions on the idea of imitation as a form of knowledge. For aristotle, “a perverted polity degenerates into democracy (a rule by the mob) which is a bad form of government iii education: a national concern – plato prescribed that everyone must be given an equal opportunity in order to prove their mettle as regards where they belong in the social stratification.
Plato promoted a government based on virtue and justice, one that should lead to the common good of everyone in the polis (city-state), including the noble, rich and poor this ideal is most identifiable as a philosophic meritocratic aristocracy or monarchy in the republic and laws, plato lays out . Plato and aristotle spoke of democracy, of oligarchy, of aristocracy, of various “typical” or “ideal” types of government forms and models of .